Educating the Humans

Killer Bees in the News

Killer bees used to be big news. Enough people are nervous around bees (even the pleasant, nearly harmless, garden bees) that the idea of massive stings is terrifying. “Bee venom is a cocktail of biologically active components that are designed to inflict pain. The honey bee stings only defensively — they don’t try to kill, they try to educate,” says May Berenbaum, a professor at the University of Illinois. Unfortunately, the Africanized honey bee sometimes forgets this important rule. Yesterday, four landscapers working at a southern Arizona house were attacked. One man died. The Douglas Fire Department Chief reported, “A witness said his face and neck were covered with bees.” That 32-year-old man died of cardiac arrest. Another man, stung more than a hundred times, was treated at the local hospital and released. The workers were part of a program teaching work skills to developmentally challenged adults. Our thoughts are with the families and friends of the people attacked and with the directors of this worthwhile charity.

It is claimed that the offending bees came from a nest of 800,000, according to the press. If that is true, it would be ten times larger than any colony I ever heard of. Most likely, someone miscopied 80,000 bees (which would still be an enormous hive) and wrote 800,000 and that number has been repeated over and over again in all the news coverage, all of which seem to buy the same story and repeat the same mistakes.

Once an error is published, it takes on a life of its own and is almost impossible to eradicate. If you look at this link, you can see how the number was picked up and unquestionably reproduced. The Weather Channel headlined with the absurdity “Arizona Landscaper Dies After 800000 Bees Attack” – only a small percentage of any hive attacks. Isn’t it enough to report the fact that hundreds of bees attacked the unfortunate workers? The Weather Channel headline is either hyperbolic exaggeration or careless fact-checking – both of which are unforgivable errors from an outfit that reports the weather. Meanwhile, the New York Daily rounded up: Nearly 1 million bees swarm Arizona men, killing one. Others repeating the 800,000 number include Gawker, Inquisitr, United Press International, The Mirror, and NBC News. Interestingly, the reporter closest to the source of the attack (Tucson News Now) wrote, “One person is dead and several others are recovering from bee stings after a huge swarm of about 300,000 bees attacked landscapers working outside a home in Douglas.” Hours after the story initially ran, CBS has written, “A swarm of about 300,000 bees killed one landscaper and critically injured another… The [Douglas Fire] Station initially reported that an estimated 800,000 bees were involved in the attack.” Better, but still not right. And why didn’t the initial reporter ask the fire department which entomologist at the station counted the bees?

Deaths from Africanized honey bees are still rare enough to make front page news as this story did on Canada’s National Post, UK’s Telegraph (which accompanied their story with a picture of a tiny cluster of bees in a tree), and the other sources (or repeaters) that I already mentioned. When the Africanized bee first arrived in the USA, there were concerns that thousands of deaths would quickly follow. This angst was led by an overly eager press and encouraged by researchers (some seeking grants to study the problem) who often were inexperienced around bees. To the novice, three bees chasing after an exposed face may elicit thoughts of a fifth apocalypse horseman. Place a young, untested grad student in Brazil next to an Africanized swarm, and he will live to tell some scary stories about the bees. So, for a few years in the mid-1970s, Africanized bees dominated the press whenever honey bees were mentioned. Today, of course, unfounded rumours of bee extinction lead the news stories. I guess that’s a bit more upbeat than the tales of wonton destruction and fears the Killer Bees once conjured. Nevertheless, exaggeration and hyperbole very quickly become tedious.

About Ron Miksha

Ron Miksha is a bee ecologist working at the University of Calgary. He is also a geophysicist and does a bit of science writing and blogging. Ron has worked as a radio broadcaster, a beekeeper, and Earth scientist. (Ask him about seismic waves.) He's based in Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
This entry was posted in Killer Bees, Stings, Strange, Odd Stuff, Swarms and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Educating the Humans

  1. I am keeping AHB survivor stock bees in Manhattan Beach CA, and find all you describe in this post the common refrain in both the public sphere and the scientific/research sphere. I absolutely despise these news stories about ANY honey bee attacks since they are interested in conveying only two pieces of information —HOW MANY bees were involved and HOW MANY stings the person received. They never give background on what may have set off the defensive response—a car smacking into a hive living in a tree is certainly going to engender a response in the bees! Or, a forklift moving wood pallets and ripping into a feral hive is not going to go well…. Or a backhoe ripping the top off a gasmeter box sequestering a feral hive is lack of due diligence on the property, irrespective of the bee issue. Recently, in Northern California a negligent beek was moving some hives in the DAYtime without closing the entrances and the bees went berserk in the neighborhood, stinging quite a few people. No description of whether they were package bees, but a immediate journalistic jump to “killer bees” was written. No criticism of the poor bee moving methods was described, either.
    And here’s one for you—I went to a talk at the Orange County bee club given by Eric Mussen, the former head of the UC Davis apiary. I was 6 mos into being a newbee, keeping ferals and interested in the title of his presentation “Dilution is not the Solution”—meaning, AHB genetics could not be expected to diminish in defensiveness from years of migration and dilution from their home country of Brazil, after Prof Kerr’s accidental release of A. scutellata queens.
    He opened his talk with a little quip about AHB —“they have been known to hit the veil with such force as to inject venom across the veil space and into the eyes of the beekeeper”!!! The collective gasp from the audience was audible. They were in his grip.
    Now, I managed to ask Mr Mussen (who is known to be a strong detractor regarding ALL feral bees) if he had ever kept any AHB stock. “No, but I have visited beekeepers who have them”
    And there you have it—a purveyor of hyperbole and hysteria, running the bee program at our major Ag school.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Ron Miksha says:

    Thanks for your comment and for relating your personal experiences. As you describe it, bees are defensive and not offensive – striking a colony with a backhoe or forklift will illicit a response. Without a spirited defence, bees would have become extinct long ago. As I discussed in the blog post, the press is dangerous when it relays its version of these sorts of stories.
    You have mentioned Dr Mussen at length. I don’t know him and can not endorse the notion that he is “a purveyor of hyperbole and hysteria” though your description of opening a talk with an image of bees injecting venom through the air towards a beekeeper’s veiled face and into her eyes is certainly memorable. Makes me think of spitting cobras. Thanks again for contributing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.